Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Home Home Slider Door Bells forum rings with hard questions for candidates

Door Bells forum rings with hard questions for candidates

HEALTHY DEMOCRACY... The Door Bells Migrant Women’s Network brought election candidates face-to-face with tough questions from Greater Shepparton residents, highlighting the importance of open debate, accountability and a healthy democracy ahead of the state election. Pictured (left to right): Fauzia Islam, Arpita Khare, Zahra Khademi, Cayla Fin, Louw Costa, Khadija Fatima, Karen Hocking, Seema Abdullah, Phillip Bryant, Kuldeep Randhawa, Shane Sali, Meena Malla, Narjis Fatima and Kulsoom Fatima. Photo: Maddison Howell

By Maddison Howell 

Passionate voices, pointed questions and heated exchanges filled the Mooroopna Education and Activity Centre as Greater Shepparton residents put election candidates under pressure at a community forum on November 10. 

Hosted by The Door Bells Migrant Women’s Network, the Ask The Candidates forum brought The Nationals’ Shane Sali, One Nation’s Phillip Bryant, Labor’s Cayla Fin, Independent Lou Costa and Victorian Socialists’ Karen Hocking together ahead of the November 28 state election. 

The evening gave migrant and multicultural residents an opportunity to question candidates directly, with organisers and attendees pressing them on issues including community safety, political representation and party loyalty. 

Questions were not always easy, with some exchanges becoming particularly heated as residents sought clearer answers on where candidates stood. 

HEALTHY DEMOCRACY… The Door Bells Migrant Women’s Network brought election candidates face-to-face with tough questions from Greater Shepparton residents, highlighting the importance of open debate, accountability and a healthy democracy ahead of the state election. Pictured (left to right): Fauzia Islam, Arpita Khare, Zahra Khademi, Cayla Fin, Louw Costa, Khadija Fatima, Karen Hocking, Seema Abdullah, Phillip Bryant, Kuldeep Randhawa, Shane Sali, Meena Malla, Narjis Fatima and Kulsoom Fatima. Photo: Maddison Howell

Mr Bryant was questioned about how he would ensure multicultural residents felt safe, as well as some of One Nation leader Pauline Hanson’s previous comments about migrants. He said he believed Ms Hanson had walked back those words and added he would be prepared to vote against his own party if he disagreed with a position. 

Mr Sali faced repeated questions about the Nationals’ decision to preference One Nation ahead of Labor. He was also heavily challenged on why he had chosen to run with the Nationals rather than as an independent, arguing party membership gave him greater access to ministers and influence in government. 

For The Door Bells president Seema Abdullah and vice president Zahra Khademi, giving residents the opportunity to ask difficult questions was exactly the point of the evening. 

“The Door Bells have organised this event for migrant communities to have a safe space in which they can ask the candidates questions and concerns they have and share their unique viewpoint,” Ms Khademi said. 

Ms Abdullah said politicians should be accessible and open to difficult conversations because they were elected by the people. 

She acknowledged emotions had run high, saying there was a line between freedom of speech and respectful discussion, with some people coming close to crossing it. 

Fellow attendee Russell Smith said he wanted to hear a different point of view, but felt the forum became chaotic towards the end. 

“It’s great for people to get their opinions out but it’s not okay to become disrespectful and aggressive,” he said.

Advertisement
Advertisement