
Shepparton Deserves Better
Dear Editor,
Back in 2022, in my Shepparton News Blog “Ernesto’s Manifesto” I questioned the logic of electing an Opposition backbencher while expecting real regional outcomes.
Borrowing from Einstein’s definition of insanity — “doing the same thing over and over expecting different results” — has been the overarching narrative in local politics for years.
I and others warned that Opposition pledges rarely turn into local deliverables.
Four years later, that warning played out. The Nationals’ 2022 campaign promised over $400M for Shepparton—including $260M for the bypass, $100M for GV Health, and $20M for the sports stadium. Yet as Kim O’Keeffe steps down after a single term, where are those deliverables? What was actually achieved beyond a steady stream of local newspaper photo opportunities?
Instead of securing funding, the Coalition’s focus has been on dragging regional Victoria backward promising to repeal Treaty legislation and waging ideological wars against the cheaper, clean energy transition regional households need.
Now, with the preselection of former Mayor Shane Sali for the Nationals, voters face total déjà vu.
Are we simply repeating the cycle of using the mayoralty as a steppingstone to an Opposition backbench, only to receive photo ops and unfulfilled pledges in return?
Independent representation like we had under Suzanna Sheed proved that focused, unaligned advocacy delivers real results like rail, school, and health funding.
Electors must ask: Do we want recycled strategies and photo ops, or a representative who will actually deliver for Shepparton?
Independents have only one master-the electorate.
This year I believe that electing a local, focussed, non-party aligned independent like Lou Costa would be the best result for the Shepparton electorate.
Yours sincerely,
Ern Meharry
Strength in Diversity
Dear Editor,
Shepparton district has a long history of diversity, from the First Peoples who cared for these lands from time immemorial to those who came later.
This diversity has shaped our community, our agricultural industries and the social fabric of our towns.
Too often we’ve seen politicians reach for the same tired playbook: creating fear, blame, and turning people’s differences into political weapons.
When difference is used to score political points, it makes us all less safe.
So we are calling on all political parties and candidates to reject racism.
To be good politicians.
To keep Article 1 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights – of which Australia is a signatory – at the forefront of their minds:
“All human beings are born free and equal in dignity and rights. They are endowed with reason and conscience and should act towards one another in a spirit of brotherhood.”
To support First Nations’ rights and self-determination.
To defend our rights to practise our cultures, speak our languages and live free from discrimination.
To work so we can have a Victoria where there is dignity and justice for all, where communities are free from racism and discrimination, where all Victorians enjoy equal rights, freedoms and protections, and thrive in safe, healthy and supportive communities.
Victoria belongs to us all.
Our diversity is our strength.
There is no Room for Racism in our politics.
A joint statement from Rumbalara Aboriginal Co-operative, Ethnic Council of Shepparton, Voices of Harmony, Shepparton Interfaith Network and Shepparton Region Reconciliation Group.
Sam Birrell MP
Dear Editor,
I congratulate all candidates standing for Shepparton District at the coming Victorian election. Voters in Shepparton now have the decision as to who represents them in a parliament that, if all the polling is correct, looks highly likely to be a majority coalition government.
Arguments around which candidate can ‘get money for the region’ ignore the fact that if there is no sustainable and responsible management of the Victorian budget, then there is less money for anyone. Good governments provide the conditions for economic growth – the proceeds of growth can be spent on infrastructure. You get a bad government, and the resultant conditions push business out of the state or out of business leaving less to be invested.
The independent camp is claiming that independent members of parliament have “secured” or “delivered” $1.6 billion for the region. This ignores the fact that a big chunk of that amount came from a federal coalition government, in which we were represented by a National party member.
An example is rail. My colleague Michael McCormack MP was Deputy Prime Minister, Leader of the Nationals and Minister for Infrastructure and Regional Development when he delivered 80 per cent of the funding ($331 million) to upgrade the Shepparton rail line and deliver nine return services a day. You don’t get a clearer example of the Nationals delivering for our region than that.
Independent MP Suzanna Sheed was a good advocate and helped in getting the Andrews Labor Government to commit, but the reality is that, without the Nationals providing federal funding, projects such as this would not have happened.
The fact is that the Victorian Labor government was able to fund early infrastructure projects through the lease of the Port of Melbourne (which I supported) and after that just decided to put everything on the credit card. Where has that left us? Looking down the barrel of $200 billion debt.
In the current conditions the well will dry up unless we have a responsible government who can guide Victoria back to prosperity.
Shane Sali is the candidate in the Shepparton contest who can be a big contributor to that. He has the experience, determination and energy to be part of a government that ensures Victoria can grow into the future. With the coalition’s 25 per cent fair share guarantee, we will see more investment in regional Victoria, and Shane has already made impressive commitments in road, health and sports infrastructure that is badly needed.
Those on the periphery can argue their case, but nothing substitutes for having a strong voice in a party of government. Shane Sali can be that voice in a Liberal-Nationals Coalition government.
Infrastructure funding has dried up across the state in recent times, as the Labor government has blowout after blowout and an obsession with its flawed suburban rail loop project. Also, Federal Labor has taken the approach of reducing their component of joint infrastructure funding to 50 per cent, which means that states, particularly financially challenged ones such as Victoria, can’t afford the projects.
Federally, a Coalition government will end Labor’s 50-50 funding split with the state for infrastructure and return it to 80-20 to revive regional infrastructure spending, which has stalled under the Albanese government.
Getting rid of one bad Labor government is a start; two would be job done.
One final note on the campaign: words do matter and care and consideration for all constituents is important.
One candidate has diminished women by saying that coaching or managing them is “like herding chickens”. Another candidate, when asked about what multiculturalism means to them, stated that migrants are “propping up the jobs other people don’t want to do”. Both women and more recent arrivals to our region have contacted me expressing dismay at these characterisations. There should be a pause for reflection.
On the other hand, Shane Sali has demonstrated he is respectful and inclusive, with a clear and strong voice that will resonate in the rooms where decisions are made.
Sam Birrell MP,
Federal Member for Nicholls
Want to have your say? Email your letters to the editor to editorial@sheppartonadviser.com.au
Please keep letters to under 200 words.





